Emmy Squared Pizza: East Village

Anthony is an amazing bartender! From the moment we arrived, he was fast, attentive, and incredibly friendly. His conversation was great, the energy was on point, and every drink he made was perfect. He didn’t go a single minute without checking on me and my friends to make sure we were taken care of. Service like his is rare. If you’re looking for a bartender who really goes above and beyond, Anthony is the one!

GF deep dish pizza will make you question whether or not it’s GF. Such good pizza with crispy bottom. Yum!!! I will crave this when I go home. We also had a great server who was warm, friendly and attentive.

The GF pizza does not taste gluten free at all it is so so so so good!!!! The small one is big for 1 person but kinda small for two hungry people. It was a bit oily (but really liked the Hawaiian!) They have a comedy club situation too, which I am sure is actually quite fun and a good pairing w their pizzas.

The gluten free pizza is actually unreal. I didn’t even believe it was gluten free. Maybe it wasn’t lol? It’s perfectly chewey and fluffy. Deep-ish crust pizza that’s absolutely perfect. It’s just indulgently fatty and delicious. All the toppings tasted super high quality. You can order online for pick up and it was only a 20 minute wait on a Saturday night. My only complaint is that it was a bittttt too oily. A small gluten free pizza (fed 2 ppl) was $31 after tax and tip.

I took 4 teenagers here and I gotta say, they all were satisfied. From pizza to burgers to wings we enjoyed all. By the end of the meal, they all were knocked out and satisfied. Was a great spot to find last minute, would definitely come back.

Went twice, once without reservation, once with. I don't really know if a reservation was needed as it wasn't really crowded. This is what we ordered: - Colony Pizza : 6.5/10, it was a little greasy, the honey was a really good addition but it was also unexpectedly spicy. - Cheesy Garlic Sticks : 7/10, pretty good but the cheese was really thick and a lot to eat if you order several apps. The garlic flavoring is really good tho. Would get again - Zia Fries: 8.5/10, really good however the second time was super salty. the fries are very crispy. The first time came with cheese sauce but the second time came with some sort of white sauce (?) - second time I'd give a 7.5/10. - Le Big Matt Burger : My friend got this burger and they gave it a 7/10 with the following reviews: "Solid 7 it's a pretty filling burger and the sauce has a nice kick. Was expecting a bigger portion for the burger and there could have been more sauce added to it. The bun was slightly burnt but very trivial and could be a plus for those who like a bit more of a char taste" - Chicken Parm Sandwich : 6.8/10 - it was a little much, the cheese wasn't bad but I think it's a lot as well. It was also a lot of chicken which is a good deal but I couldn't finish the entire sandwich. only half. Drinks: - Emotional Damage : 6.5/10 - I knew it was going to be a little sour, but it was extremely sour at first sip. still a little refreshing but nonetheless sour. - Not from the Stand : 7.5/10 - this was very refreshing, not as alcohol tasty as one may like, but I don't exactly love the taste of alcohol. would get again. - Paloma : 7/10 - I don't really remember the taste of this as I got it in 2023, but I think it was pretty good. A little heavy on the alcohol but I'd get it again. Service: At the beginning, when we first seated, our server did kind of feel like he was rushing us, came over twice while we were reviewing what we wanted to get. I asked about what drink to get as I wasn't too fond about the taste of alcohol, and I asked which he would recommend, but he said it differs person to person, he recommended the emotional damage which wasn't bad but a little too sour for my taste. While dining, they did drop by a couple times to ask about our experience and stuff. It wasn't too bad but we felt a little rushed. Overall, I would come back again but I also want to try the other Emmys Squared locations in NYC.

Fantastic gluten free pizza! My wife is ‘t gluten free and loved it! Detroit style :)

It had been a while since we’d visited the city together as a family, and we decided to stop by for dinner with our daughter before heading home. The pizza was just as delicious as we remembered, and the team went out of their way to make us feel welcome, from opening the door for our stroller and offering genuinely thoughtful service throughout our meal. Their kindness helped turn an ordinary dinner into a small but unforgettable family moment, perfect for a low-key birthday celebration. And the music? Absolutely spot-on. Shout out to the staff at this location!